Why cultural fit matters when hiring: real world example

by

I first read about Carol Bartz in a Business Week, four or so years ago. At the time, she was the highly successful CEO of AutoCad. During her leadership AutoCad had become the largest software company in the design and engineering space, earning both the company and Carol tremendous accolades in the technology industry.  The article didn’t focus a great deal on her straightforward and at times colorful language, but it did characterize her as no nonsense.

Fast forward a few years and she was hired on to Yahoo as the CEO. A CEO who the board hoped would do what she had done for AutoCad; complete a successful technology business turn around. At the time, Yahoo was an ailing internet visage of the dot.com era. Stuck between its role as a search engine vs. its destination portal and marketing advertising business. Though she reportedly had success on both the cost and margin part of her initial goals, revenue growth still eludes Yahoo three years after she was hired. As Yahoo struggled to completely revitalize itself, some of Carol’s greatest hits became well chronicled and fodder for anti- Carol advocates. And this week she was fired, abruptly, by mostly the same board of directors that hired her three years earlier. 
If you read through the myriad of articles telling the behind the scenes information of what happened and even Carol’s own recounting of the events, you can put together a picture what happens when you don’t hire for a cultural fit.  Although Carol is from all accounts as talented as any technology executive in her era, both male and female, she has a no nonsense personality sprinkled with instances of using off color comments that make some people uncomfortable.  Part of that same personality, which undoubtedly allowed her to succeed in her career (especially in an industry dominated by sometimes confident to the point of arrogant males, Steve Ballmer, Steve Jobs, Larry Ellison, Mark Hurd to name a few) appears to have led to her downfall at Yahoo. I’m not taking sides on who is “right” in this situation, or even if this is due to other inequalities between male and female executives, but the contention that such behavior at Yahoo was somewhat unexpected or took people aback, means one of three things to me:
  1. Yahoo ignored the potential cultural and personality conflicts when they hired her
  2. Yahoo thought it could change Carol’s behavior
  3. Yahoo did not do enough background research to find out such thing
In my mind, option 3 speaks to a different problem. But if it’s either option 1 or 2, or some combination of the two, then the same board that hired her should be looking in the mirror over the next few weeks as they fight the firestorm they in part caused. Culture matters. 
By the way Carol, your brand of “culture” is completely fine with me. I don’t like a–holes either. 

READ MORE

The Magic of Mortals

The Magic of Mortals

Daily we wake up to new developments in automation, Artificial Intelligence (AI), and Machine Learning (ML). Across sectors and industries, automated solutions prove highly successful in surpassing the capacity of the human brain for certain tasks, improving...

read more
Leveling Up: How to Hone Your Skills at Home

Leveling Up: How to Hone Your Skills at Home

Leaders have been trying to crack the code on talent development for years. Recent studies have shown, however, that strength-focused leadership [read: intentionally elevating the qualities that already come naturally to us] is the clear winner for developing talent...

read more
Fake Case Study: Jack of all trades vs. Master of One

Fake Case Study: Jack of all trades vs. Master of One

  Listen to any earnings call or executive presentation and you will likely hear the terms “top line” and “bottom line.” These are words used to describe a business’s performance. According to Investopedia, the words are defined as follows: Top line refers to the...

read more
Your Personality Is Showing

Your Personality Is Showing

There I was, minding my own business one evening, digging into my organization's SEO performance (as one does), when I came across something interesting. Search terms related to "MBTI" — or the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator, developed by Katherine Cook Briggs and Isabel...

read more
Lessons From a Change Manager Who Hates Change

Lessons From a Change Manager Who Hates Change

Hello. My name is Monique, and I’m a change manager who hates change.   After years of receiving “consulting therapy” from various mentors, I am now able to say these words out loud and proudly. But for a long time, it felt more like an admission of guilt. I mean, who...

read more
Creativity as a Cure

Creativity as a Cure

The topic of creative solutioning has been front and center these days as we talk more and more about organizational adaptability in the face of dynamic and uncertain times. For example, I recently read about a project that got me thinking about specific priorities...

read more
Thought Ensemble, a Pariveda Company — Why Now?

Thought Ensemble, a Pariveda Company — Why Now?

Big news over here as we close out the year - we have been acquired by Pariveda, a 750-person consulting firm in 12 markets across North America! We are now “Thought Ensemble, a Pariveda Company” and I’ll be serving as the Managing Vice President continuing to lead...

read more
Thought Ensemble Joins Pariveda Solutions!

Thought Ensemble Joins Pariveda Solutions!

Dallas, December 9, 2021 /PRNewswire/ -- Pariveda, a leader specializing in solving complex technology and business problems, announces the acquisition of Thought Ensemble. With the addition of Thought Ensemble, Pariveda now provides holistic business strategy,...

read more
Thoughts on Colorado’s Equal Pay for Equal Work Act

Thoughts on Colorado’s Equal Pay for Equal Work Act

It was about a year ago that we first started hearing about Colorado’s Equal Pay for Equal Work Act (SB19-085) and I knew it was going to be national news. We’d just gotten past the “Rocky Mountain High” jokes, and our lovely state was trying to break new ground...

read more